The annual budgeting process is an important exercise for every company to go through in the lead-up to the beginning of their fiscal year. While some argue this is an outdated approach that doesn’t adapt to the ever-changing needs of a business, the opportunity to think strategically about the business over a longer time period than just the next three months is necessary for management teams to achieve long-term goals. Here are some guiding principles I’ve learned from working with companies across virtually every business sector.
Business Goals Are Your Guiding Principles
Know what the business is trying to accomplish in the next year and beyond – is it gaining market share, expanding into a new product line, maximizing cash flow distributions to owners, preparing for a sale or capital markets event? Without these guiding principles it is impossible to evaluate the budget or recurring monthly actuals as “good” or “bad”; the various goals a business could target have different performance expectations and metrics.
Revenue First
The sales projections of a business will dictate expense categories – be them marketing requirements, staffing, or manufacturing/inventory needs. So start there. All department heads on the management team should ultimately be budgeting expenses according to a unified sales or revenue projection. As for those top line projections? Revenue leaders should start at the most basic building block, whether that’s the account, client, or unit economics of a product. From there management teams can evaluate all the variable costs required to achieve those sales projections given the needs of a particular account, client, or sales channel. The variable costs needs then inform the business’s ability to support fixed operating costs.
Right-Size Fixed Expenses
The biggest part of any business’s fixed operating expenses is salaries and its people. The primary benefit of an annual budgeting process is that it lets businesses look at the next twelve months to ensure a) the current size of the staff fits with where the business is expected to go and b) any anticipating hiring can be supported if the budget numbers are achieved. At times the hiring process can take six months or more so having this longer-term view is paramount. Beyond personnel, each department head should engage in an expense review by vendor and category that fall within their P&L. Evaluating past spend levels can inform what is required moving forward.
Operating Budget Does Not Equal Cash
An operating budget that projects out revenue and expenses does not equal cash – items such as inventory needs, production lead times, vendor terms, customer payment terms, capital expenditures (“CapEx”), and debt service payments all must be considered. Once a draft budget has been developed with the management team, it is critical for the finance team to input those projections into an integrated financial model to forecast items like working capital need, line of credit/debt financing, and cash conversion. Understanding cash needs – and the timing of those cash needs – is critical to any planning process.
Review Monthly…Backwards and Forwards
Most management teams will engage in a backward-looking “budget to actual” comparison to identify deviations from plan, both from a revenue standpoint as well as expense spending. This is a best practice as long as teams learn from those deviations in managing the business moving forward. Many management teams do not use their budgets to plan the upcoming month, but this is also a best practice. Some of the highest performing companies I’ve worked with will spend management team time to review the upcoming month’s budget, projections, and expenses to evaluate feasibility or any potential changes that might need to be made. This is critical for turning your annual budget document into an actionable plan that is relevant to your business in every month.
Is Annual Planning Dead? Long Live Rolling Budgets?
There is value in the annual planning process – it allows for management teams to think across a longer time horizon than daily operating demands allow, and provides the necessary context for long-term items like hiring new personnel or investments in capital expenditures. Where many management teams fail is that they do not then use that annual plan in their daily/weekly/monthly running of the business. Budgets should be used to measure business performance and guide near-term execution. Re-forecasts should be done when there is a material change in the expectations of the business, not simply because minor deviations occur from the plan – understanding how actual results deviated from the original plan is a valuable learning tool to better plan the business into the future. Certain businesses will also benefit from “rolling” budgets that continually project out into the future, however the time horizon for those rolling budgets needs to balance the need for long-term planning with realistic visibility, and to be done right require time commitment from management teams that need to be accounted for apart from the daily running of the business.